Electric Car Pros & Cons

Electric cars are in the news a lot at the moment, largely because air quality has become such a hot topic. Conventionally powered vehicles (petrol and diesel) are one of the key sources of pollution in busy city centres, and one of the main advantages of electric cars is that you’ll be doing your bit to reduce air pollution.

Electric vehicles have been around since the dawn of motoring at the turn of the 20th century but it’s only within the past decade that they have become a mass-market proposition. The first mainstream model designed from the outset as an electric car was the Nissan Leaf (launched in 2010), and since then the market has expanded with models from BMW, Tesla and Renault among others.

There are many things to consider when deliberating on the benefits of electric cars and whether or not an electric car is right for you. We’ve listed some pros and cons that are worth mulling over before you decide to make the switch.

Advantages of electric cars:

Improve local air quality
More efficient, so fuel costs are lower
Very easy to drive, nippy around town
Cheaper to service (BEVs)
Grants reduce purchase costs (BEV and PHEV)
Can refuel quickly (HEVs and PHEVs)

Disadvantages of electric cars:

More costly to buy
Lose value more quickly
Patchy public charging network (BEVs and PHEVs)
Often cost more to insure
The range is often limited (BEVs)
Sometimes no more frugal than a normal car (HEVs and PHEVs)
Can take a long time to charge (BEVs)

While it’s only recently that affordable and usable electric cars have been available in significant numbers, for years before that there was also an array of hybrid cars to choose from. While a hybrid car isn’t electric, it is electrified, and that’s an important distinction that many people are unaware of. Not only is there a difference, but to complicate things further, there are five types of electrified vehicle:

Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV)

These are electric cars that are powered solely by electricity stored in battery packs. Buy one and you’ll have to charge it up at home, at work or from a charging point such as on the motorway. There’s no on-board back-up power supply (i.e. an engine), so get caught with a flat battery and you’ll have to be recovered. BEVs include the Nissan Leaf, Renault Zoe and all Teslas, while BMW offers an electric-only i3.

Hybrid Electric Vehicle (HEV)

A hybrid is an electrified car that features either a petrol or diesel engine, although it’s rarely the latter, as diesel engines cost more to make than petrols. This engine drives the wheels and is backed up by an electric motor powered by a battery pack. The batteries are charged up by the engine, or when the car is slowed (either by using engine braking or the car’s foot brake). Examples include the Toyota Prius and lots of other Toyota and Lexus models, along with the Bentley Bentayga and Kia Niro.

Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle (PHEV)

HEVs have an electric-only range of typically just four miles because of the size of the battery pack. By fitting a larger set of batteries the electric-only range can be increased to more like 30 miles, with efficiency being improved by having the ability to recharge the car via a mains supply. Such cars are called plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) and they bridge the gap between a pure electric car (BEV) and a conventional hybrid in that it contains the best elements of both. As a result these cars are costly but they have still become much more common over the past couple of years, with the introduction of models by BMW, Mercedes, Volvo, Volkswagen and many more.

Range extender (REX)

The range extender is much like a plug-in hybrid to use, as it features a petrol engine and a battery pack. However, the wheels are always driven by electric motors powered by the battery pack which is charged up by the engine. So the engine acts solely as a generator, but there’s always the option of charging up the battery pack from a mains supply. The now-defunct Vauxhall Ampera and Chevrolet Volt were the first range extenders to be sold in the UK; the BMW i3 and i8 are still on sale though.

Hydrogen fuel cell

Just to complicate things there’s a fifth type of electrified car, and that’s the hydrogen fuel cell. Available in tiny numbers, the only model available in the UK is the Toyota Mirai, although Hyundai sold a hydrogen ix35 until recently. Although car makers have been developing hydrogen fuel cell models for decades, the technology is still in its infancy. So is the infrastructure as there are just four hydrogen refuelling stations in the whole of the UK, three of which are in London. The difficulty with making a viable hydrogen fuel cell car is reducing the cost, improving the reliability and shrinking the technology to a suitable size. While mass-market hydrogen fuel cell cars are still some way off, the technology is being used in buses, which in diesel form are one of the key sources of pollution in urban environments. By switching to hydrogen this pollution is eliminated altogether, as the only emission from a hydrogen fuel cell is water.

Although there are five different electrification technologies, they all get lumped together as AFVs, or Alternatively Fuelled Vehicles. So an AFV is simply a vehicle that’s electrified, which can mean that it’s pure electric, a hybrid or a range extender, with the odd hydrogen fuel cell thrown in for good measure. Such vehicles are starting to prove big business as they accounted for 4.6% of the cars sold in the UK up to the end of September, which equates to over 94,000 units. But is an AFV right for you?

Richard Dredge

Thinking of buying or selling a car? Visit hpi.co.uk for the best information available on any car